Bolzano court rejects betting venue’s challenge to ban after licence expiry
Regulation2 min read
Summary
Bolzano's regional administrative court rejected a betting operator's challenge to the municipality's order stopping its activity, finding that its five-year authorisation had expired on 30 August 2023. A previous ruling had overturned a revocation based on distance rules but did not extend the permit; the court also held that a 2024 transition period could not revive an expired licence.
Bolzano's regional administrative court has rejected a betting operator's challenge to a municipal order stopping its activity, finding the appeal partly inadmissible and partly unfounded in a judgment published on 18 November 2026. The municipality found in May 2025 that the licence had expired on 30 August 2023 and ordered the venue to stop operating immediately and return its authorisation.
The venue had been authorised to take horse racing and sports bets on 30 August 2018. The authorisation, issued by the president of the autonomous province, was valid for five years from its issue date. The province revoked it in 2019 because several sensitive sites were within 300 metres of the venue.
The operator challenged the revocation and obtained a favourable Council of State ruling in January 2024, which found that the provincial rules examined applied to gaming machine venues rather than betting venues. The company argued that the municipality's later order conflicted with that decision. The Council of State clarified in June 2026 that overturning the revocation concerned only the incorrect application of distance rules and did not decide the question of the five-year expiry, the Bolzano court said.
The court rejected on procedural grounds the operator's argument that the licence should be permanent under the TULPS and its implementing regulation: the company had not challenged the five-year term in the 2018 authorisation. Any objection to the clause's legality had to be raised within “sessanta giorni” of the authorisation's issue. A separate request for a declaration of permanent validity, made in a reply brief, was also inadmissible.
The court rejected an alternative request to treat the licence as valid until at least July 2026 under a transition period in provincial law no. 2 of 2024. The provision gives authorisations that do not comply with the new distance rules two years, but applies only to those still valid when the law took effect on 19 July 2024, the court said.
The court rejected objections to the constitutionality of extending distance rules to betting, finding that they were unrelated to the grounds for the municipality's order. The municipality had established expiry using the original authorisation, without applying the new distance rules. The ruling did not amount to a general assessment of the provincial rules' constitutionality.
The court ordered the appellant to reimburse the municipality and the autonomous province of Bolzano “3mila euro” each in legal costs, for a total of “6mila euro” plus statutory additions.