TAR confirms Bolzano betting shop closure over expired licence
Regulation2 min read
Summary
The Administrative Court of Trentino-Alto Adige upheld Bolzano’s order stopping a betting shop after finding that its licence expired in August 2023. The court said the five-year term in the 2018 authorisation should have been challenged within 60 days and rejected claims that transitional rules applied.
The Administrative Court of Trentino-Alto Adige has upheld Bolzano’s order stopping a betting shop from operating after its licence expired, rejecting the company’s appeal. The autonomous province of Bolzano issued the authorisation on 30 August 2018 for a five-year term.
The company argued that public security licences had no expiry date following changes introduced in 2001. The court said any challenge to the five-year term should have been brought against the 2018 authorisation within 60 days of its issue. It ruled out setting aside the duration clause, saying this would circumvent procedural deadlines.
The court rejected the argument that an earlier Council of State decision prevented the municipality from determining that the licence had expired. In 2024, the Council of State annulled the province’s revocation of the authorisation over the application of provincial distance rules to betting shops. That decision concerned minimum distances from sensitive sites, not the licence’s duration. The Council of State clarified in a June 2026 judgment that it had not ruled on the authorisation’s expiry.
The company had sought to use a transitional provision in a 2024 provincial law, which allows two years for authorised activities that conflict with new distance limits to cease. The court rejected that request, saying the provision applied to authorisations still valid when the law took effect on 19 July 2024, whereas this licence expired on 30 August 2023.
The judges said they did not need to examine challenges to the constitutionality of the new provincial distance rules. The municipality had not applied the new limits retroactively, but had established that the original licence had expired. The appeal was declared partly inadmissible and partly unfounded.