Bolzano administrative court upholds closure of betting shop over expired licence
Regulation3 min read
Summary
Bolzano’s regional administrative court rejected a company’s challenge to the municipality’s closure of a betting shop, finding the appeal partly inadmissible and partly unfounded. The court confirmed that the licence expired on 31 December 2015 and said the expiry date should have been challenged within 60 days of issue.
Bolzano's regional administrative court has rejected a company's challenge to the municipality's closure of a betting shop in the city. The court found the appeal partly inadmissible and partly unfounded, confirming that the shop's licence expired on 31 December 2015. The municipality had found that the licence had expired on 6 May 2025 and ordered betting activity to stop immediately.
The provincial president issued the licence on 4 March 2015, valid until 31 December that year. It was provisional pending the resolution of a dispute over administrative responsibility.
In 2017, the province revoked the licence under a provincial distance rule because several sensitive locations were within 300 metres of the shop. The Council of State overturned that decision on 25 January 2024, ruling that the provincial rule applied to gaming halls with machines, not betting shops.
The operator submitted a new certified notice of commencement to the municipality in 2024 to obtain authorisation to take bets. The municipality then prohibited the activity because the measures it had requested to regularise the planning application had not been provided within 60 days. In the same notice, it began proceedings concerning the expiry of the 2015 licence.
The company argued that the municipality had acted contrary to the Council of State's 2024 ruling, which it said covered the licence's duration. The administrative court rejected that argument, citing a 3 June 2026 Council of State ruling that clarified the earlier decision concerned only the distance rule.
The company also argued that changes to public security law and its regulations in 2001 made such licences permanent. The court found that argument inadmissible because it concerned the 2015 authorisation, which was not challenged in the proceedings. It said the company should have challenged the expiry date within 60 days of the licence being issued. Without a timely appeal, the date could no longer be challenged or disregarded by the court, as the company had requested.
The court rejected the company's argument that the provisional licence remained effective after responsibility was transferred to municipalities. The judges said that transfer established only which authority held responsibility. They said the clause meant the licence would have ceased to be effective immediately if responsibility had passed to police headquarters before 31 December 2015.
Alternatively, the company sought recognition of the licence as valid until at least 18 July 2026 under a 2024 provincial law. That law took effect on 19 July 2024, extending the distance rule to betting shops and providing for non-compliant licences to expire within two years. The court said the rule applied to licences still valid when the law took effect, unlike the shop's licence, which had already expired in 2015. It considered the company's request to refer the provincial law to the Constitutional Court irrelevant because the municipality had relied on the licence's expiry date rather than that law. The judges observed that the two-year period in the provincial law had since passed. The court said the shop could not obtain a new authorisation because it did not meet the distance requirements.