Fourth Circuit rejects Kalshi bid to block Maryland gambling enforcement
Regulation2 min read
Summary
The Fourth Circuit on 17 November upheld a ruling that left Maryland gaming regulators able to pursue their sports-wagering case against Kalshi. In a 2-1 decision, the court refused Kalshi's request for an injunction, but did not resolve the underlying lawsuit; Maryland has not said whether it will take further enforcement action.
The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the denial of an injunction sought by Kalshi, leaving Maryland regulators able to pursue enforcement of state sports wagering laws against the exchange. The decision did not settle Kalshi's underlying lawsuit, and Maryland has not said whether it will take further enforcement action.
The 17 November ruling affirmed a federal district court's August 2025 rejection of Kalshi's request to halt Maryland's enforcement actions. In April 2025, state regulators sent a cease-and-desist letter alleging that Kalshi was offering sports wagering without the required Maryland licence. Kalshi contended that its designation as an exchange regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission placed it under exclusive federal oversight through the Commodity Exchange Act, superseding state gambling regulations. At the preliminary injunction stage, the Fourth Circuit rejected that argument in a 2-1 decision.
Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker found that Kalshi had not established grounds to block enforcement, though their legal reasoning differed. Gregory concluded that Congress had not clearly displaced state authority over gambling, even if sports event contracts were federally regulated swaps. Thacker found that the contracts were not swaps under federal commodities law and therefore lay outside the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction. Judge DeAndrea Benjamin dissented, arguing that the contracts were swaps subject to exclusive federal regulation.
The Third Circuit ruled for Kalshi in April, preventing New Jersey regulators from applying state gambling restrictions to the exchange. The Ninth Circuit subsequently sided with Nevada in August, while the Sixth Circuit supported Ohio and Tennessee in September. Three federal appeals courts have now ruled against Kalshi's attempts to avoid state gambling rules, while one has ruled in its favour.
Kalshi must limit sports and other event contracts under a Washington state court order that includes geolocation controls. Following court decisions, Michigan has been able to bar Kalshi's sports wagering offerings; Louisiana has a temporary ban. California tribes have also won court support for limits on sports event contracts on tribal lands. Utah has pursued civil and criminal enforcement against Kalshi. State authorities brought criminal charges against the company's cofounders in October.
New Jersey regulators have asked the justices to review the Third Circuit decision, and prediction market companies have sought review of rulings against them in appellate courts. The Supreme Court has yet to agree to take up the underlying dispute.