Fourth Circuit allows Maryland to enforce gambling laws against Kalshi
Regulation2 min read
Summary
The Fourth Circuit affirmed a lower court’s refusal to block Maryland regulators from enforcing state sports wagering laws against Kalshi. The 2-1 ruling leaves the 1 August 2025 order in place, allowing Maryland to pursue enforcement against Kalshi’s sports event contracts while the judges in the majority differed on their reasoning.
The Fourth Circuit appeals court has upheld a refusal to block Maryland from enforcing its sports wagering laws against Kalshi, clearing the way for state action over its sports event contracts. The panel ruled by a two-to-one vote, with the judges in the majority reaching the same result for different reasons.
Kalshi remains without a preliminary injunction under an order issued on 1 August 2025 by U.S. District Judge Adam Abelson. Maryland had postponed enforcement pending the appeal and can now ask a state court to prohibit Kalshi’s sports contracts.
Judge Roger Gregory declined to decide whether the contracts were swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act. He said Kalshi had not shown that federal law clearly displaced Maryland’s gambling powers or that the company could not comply with both sets of rules. Gregory noted that Kalshi’s contracts traded under its own certification rather than CFTC approval.
Judge Stephanie Thacker concluded that the contracts did not meet the definition of a swap because they paid out on a game’s result rather than whether it took place. She noted that Kalshi’s lawyer had conceded at oral argument that the company advertised itself as sports betting a year earlier.
The contracts were swaps and federal law displaced Maryland law because Kalshi was a CFTC-designated contract market, Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin concluded in dissent. Her interpretation excluded parlays and props from the definition of swaps. She would have overturned the order and sent the case back for the lower court to assess the remaining injunction factors.
State licensing rules require sportsbooks to safeguard customer data, avoid deceptive ads and keep marketing from people vulnerable to problem gambling, Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown said. He said the ruling requires Kalshi to meet the consumer protection standards applicable to other sportsbooks serving Maryland residents. The decision affirmed state authority over sports wagering, Maryland gaming commission acting director Jeremy Baker said. A Kalshi spokesperson cited the judges’ differing opinions as evidence that there was no unified legal argument against prediction markets.
A separate consumer protection suit brought by Baltimore targets Kalshi and Polymarket; Kalshi has dismissed it as political theatre, CBS Baltimore reported. Kalshi could request a rehearing by the full Fourth Circuit or bring the case to the Supreme Court. New Jersey sought Supreme Court review of the Third Circuit ruling in September, while Kalshi obtained an extension of its response deadline to 7 December.