SectorWire
SearchRegister
MenuClose

Sicilian administrative court upholds seven-day betting-shop suspension in Catania

Enforcement & compliance2 min read

Summary

The Sicilian Regional Administrative Court’s Catania section rejected a betting-shop owner’s appeal against a seven-day suspension ordered by the Catania police commissioner. The court found that repeated police checks supported the authority’s view that people with criminal records frequented the premises regularly, and treated the suspension as a preventive measure rather than a penalty.

TAR Sicilia's Catania section has rejected a betting-shop owner's appeal against a seven-day suspension of the premises' authorisations. The court also rejected the owner's claim for compensation and ordered each side to bear its own legal costs.

Catania's police commissioner ordered the suspension under article 100 of the TULPS after people with criminal records, particularly for drug dealing and theft, were repeatedly found on the premises. Police said people with criminal records had become regular visitors, requiring immediate action to protect public order and safety.

The measure was based on three checks. During the first, officers noticed a group on the premises that included three people with criminal records. In the second, eight people were identified, six of whom had already been recorded in a police database. In the third, three people with criminal records were found inside and had stayed for a long time. The court said the checks, conducted close together, showed that visits by customers with criminal records were regular rather than occasional.

The owner had argued that the visits were incidental and occasional, and that the shop was still closed at the time of the first check. The court said the records contradicted the owner's account of the first check. A service record by Nesima police officers placed the group inside the business, not outside. The owner also challenged the failure to give notice of the proceedings and the adequacy of the reasons for the measure.

The court said article 100 suspensions are preventive measures rather than penalties, citing case law. The measure aims to prevent danger to the public and does not depend on the owner's responsibility, the court said. A clear connection between the premises' activity and repeated visits by dangerous people is sufficient to impose it. Police checks are sufficient to establish that people have criminal records without further inquiries into their criminal histories, and the same people need not be present at each check. The judges said article 100 measures are inherently urgent, justifying the absence of advance notice.

Before going to court, the owner had made an administrative appeal to the Catania prefecture, which was rejected.

Request a correction

Flag an issue

Keep reading