Mexico’s Supreme Court rejects Operadora Cantabria challenge to MXN546m tax guarantee
Regulation1 min read
Summary
Mexico's Supreme Court reportedly denied Operadora Cantabria's amparo challenging a guarantee required to suspend collection of a MXN546m tax credit. The unanimous decision left in place the Federal Administrative Justice Court's requirement; the credit concerns 2013 IEPS and was determined by the tax authority in 2024.
Mexico's Supreme Court rejected Operadora Cantabria's challenge to a guarantee required to suspend collection of a MXN546m tax credit, leaving the requirement in place. Operadora Cantabria operates Codere casinos in Mexico.
The court approved the decision unanimously, based on a draft presented by Justice Sara Irene Herrerías Guerra. The Federal Administrative Justice Court had made suspension of collection conditional on a guarantee being provided to the authority. Herrerías Guerra said the guarantee was required for the suspension to take effect.
In its challenge to a provision of the Federal Administrative Litigation Procedure Law, the operator argued that the requirement violated its rights to equality, legal certainty and access to justice.
Mexico's tax authority, SAT, determined in 2024 that Operadora Cantabria owed MXN546m in special production and services tax for the 2013 fiscal year. The SAT had initially assessed Codere's tax credit at MXN561,371,682, but the operator won annulment of that decision at the Federal Administrative Justice Court. The SAT then reopened its audit and determined that the company's tax credit had risen to MXN1,272,385,927 over time. Codere brought a further annulment case, but the SAT decision was upheld and a subsequent constitutional challenge was rejected.