Mexico’s SCJN denies Codere amparo over MXN546m tax guarantee
Regulation2 min read
Summary
Mexico’s Supreme Court, the SCJN, unanimously denied Operadora Cantabria’s amparo challenging a guarantee required to suspend collection of a MXN546m tax credit. The SAT assessed the credit against the Codere casino operator for IEPS relating to 2013, and the court upheld the guarantee condition imposed by the TFJA.
Mexico’s SCJN unanimously rejected an amparo brought by Operadora Cantabria against a guarantee required to suspend collection of an MXN546m tax credit, the court ruled. Operadora Cantabria operates Codere casinos in Mexico.
The SAT assessed the MXN546m credit against Operadora Cantabria in 2024 for IEPS tax relating to the 2013 fiscal year. The TFJA granted a definitive suspension of collection, conditional on payment of a guarantee to the tax authority. In its amparo, the company challenged a provision of the Federal Administrative Litigation Procedure Law, arguing that the charge violated its rights to equality, legal certainty and access to justice. The justices approved a draft ruling by justice Sara Irene Herrerías Guerra.
In a separate case, the SCJN confirmed the SAT’s collection of MXN1,272m from Codere in May 2025, relating to a tax credit from 2008. The TFJA had previously ruled for Codere, after which the SAT issued a new resolution and increased the credit to MXN1,900m. The company brought another annulment claim, and the dispute reached the SCJN. The court’s then First Chamber confirmed the credit’s validity by a majority of three votes, allowing the SAT to continue collection. With adjustments and surcharges, the debt reached approximately MXN1,900m.
As part of that dispute, the SAT auctioned 50% of the shares in Centros de Entretenimiento de las Américas, known as ICELA, in August. ICELA operates the Hipódromo de las Américas and 65 Codere casinos in Mexico. It operates the Yak and Sports Books betting shops, Centro Citibanamex and Granja Las Américas. Codere has operated in Mexico since 1998 and has 76 gambling venues under the Yak, Royal Yak, Jackpot and Codere brands.
The auction ran from 11 to 18 August on the SubastaSAT portal. Its minimum starting price was MXN3.33m, equivalent to two-thirds of the valuation. The SAT recommended bids of at least MXN5m, the full value of the shareholding.