Coral files EU complaint over Italian bingo concession fees
Regulation3 min read
Summary
Coral S.r.l.’s representative filed a formal complaint with the European Commission on 13 November 2026, alleging that Italy’s bingo concession arrangements breach EU law. The complaint challenges the ADM’s 81-tier fee system, arguing that its minimum and maximum charges disadvantage smaller operators; the allegations have not been established as findings.
Coral S.r.l.’s representative Cono Vittorio Germanotta has filed a complaint with the European Commission alleging that Italy’s bingo concession arrangements breach EU law. The complaint was received on 13 November 2026.
It challenges an ADM decision of 31 July 2026 that introduced 81 fee bands based on individual halls’ takings. Halls taking up to €1.2m pay a minimum of €3,250 a month, or €39,000 a year. Charges rise through the bands to a maximum of €9,000 a month, or €108,000 a year, for halls taking more than €17m. Coral argues that the minimum and maximum charges make the system regressive, favouring larger concession holders over smaller businesses.
The complaint calculates that a hall with annual takings of €500,000 would pay €39,000, equivalent to 7.8% of takings and 43.33% of the concession holder’s gross margin. It puts the annual fee for a hall taking €6m at €60,000, or 1% of takings. In documents sent to parliamentarians, the complainant estimates that the 81-band system could yield about €70m less for the Treasury than a flat rate of 1.2%.
The bands replaced a fixed fee for 2025 to 2026, initially introduced by ADM on 9 December 2025 and extended to all concession holders on 26 February 2026. Germanotta alleges that the new system fails to implement fully a Court of Justice of the European Union ruling of 20 March 2025 and continues to discriminate against smaller operators. The complaint alleges incompatibility with Article 43 of Directive 2014/23/EU, Articles 49 and 56 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU and principles of proportionality, equal treatment and competition. The complainant says the court found the earlier unilateral extension regime incompatible with the directive because it combined an increased flat fee, a ban on transfers and a requirement to accept an extension to enter future tenders.
The complaint proposes replacing the bands with a 1.2% charge on each hall’s actual takings, without minimum or maximum fees. It describes an original concession model that allocated 70% of takings to prizes, 11% to tax, 1% to the central controller and 18% to the concession holder’s gross remuneration.
The complaint also challenges a rule requiring a hall moving to another municipality to be at least 30 kilometres from the nearest hall there. Germanotta contrasts that with a one-kilometre requirement for a move within the same municipality. The complaint says ADM refused Coral’s proposed move from Torrenova to Casoria on 29 May 2026 and acknowledged in a document dated 10 July 2026 that the Torrenova hall was uneconomic. Coral argues that the restriction affects freedom of establishment and prevents operators from responding to proven financial difficulties.
Germanotta asks the Commission to consider infringement proceedings or urgently open an EU Pilot procedure over the alleged breaches. The complaint seeks Commission intervention to prevent the bands being written into Italian law, a proportional fee and oversight of a new European tender with transparent and equal access for smaller businesses.
In a separate submission to parliamentarians, Germanotta warns that Article 27 of budget bill A.C. 3174-bis could give the 81 bands a legislative basis. One proposed amendment would replace the relevant provisions with a 1.2% charge and recalculate payments already made, with possible refunds or offsets. An alternative proposal would remove those provisions from the bill.