Nine Democratic senators urge CFTC to withdraw prediction-market guidance
Regulation3 min read
Summary
Nine Democratic senators urged the CFTC on 16 November to withdraw guidance that prevents federally regulated prediction markets from restricting access by state or tribal land. The American Gaming Association said 82% of registered voters in its national poll favoured treating the platforms under gambling rules rather than financial regulation.
Nine Democratic senators called on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission on 16 November to withdraw guidance barring federally regulated prediction markets from restricting access by state or tribal land. In their letter, they also told chairman Michael Selig to retain the agency’s prediction-market records and correspondence from 2025 onward.
The senators argued that the directive clashes with judicial rulings ordering operators to disable some contracts where the products are legally contested in states and tribal areas. They also accused the commission of appearing to encourage markets to offer barred contracts in defiance of court orders while litigation continues.
The CFTC issued its interpretation on 5 November, drawing on a regulation that requires equal trading access for eligible participants on designated contract markets. Exchanges have a 30-day window to remove location restrictions conflicting with the rule or explain to the Division of Market Oversight why they cannot. Exchanges are also expected to ensure that brokers and other intermediaries sending them trades do not impede access. The agency said it would assess situations individually before choosing whether to take action.
Hours before the guidance was published, federal judge Jacqueline Scott Corley had issued an injunction keeping Kalshi’s sports contracts off the lands of California’s Blue Lake Rancheria and Chicken Ranch Rancheria of Me-Wuk Indians. In July, the CFTC directed Kalshi to honour open sports positions despite a Michigan state court order. The agency issued another emergency order concerning New York in August.
Federal lawyers from the CFTC and Justice Department went to court against Arkansas last week, seeking to stop attorney general Tim Griffin’s case against Kalshi. The following day, the lawyers filed against Louisiana, arguing that a state judge’s geofencing order violated the access rule. Louisiana was the 12th state the agency had taken to court.
Age checks for customers 21 or older were supported by 74%, while 74% also wanted advertising to encourage responsible play and provide a helpline. Licensing by state gaming regulators was supported by 71%, and 70% wanted platforms to honour state gambling self-exclusion lists. Half of those surveyed incorrectly believed prediction markets already had state sportsbook licences. The online poll reached 2,268 registered voters aged at least 21 from 2 to 18 September 2026; the AGA put its margin of error at plus or minus 2 percentage points. AGA president and CEO Bill Miller said Americans across party lines and 47 attorneys general agreed that prediction markets should have the same rules, oversight and consumer protections as state- and tribal-licensed sportsbooks. The association represents the U.S. casino industry and counts state-licensed sportsbook operators among its members.
Texas Republican senator Ted Cruz, who chairs the Senate Commerce Committee, is drafting a bill to prevent prediction markets from listing gambling-related contracts, including sports, without state or tribal approval. The bill was expected after the midterm elections. House Republicans Adrian Smith of Nebraska and Blake Moore of Utah have each filed prediction-market bills.