New York attorney general seeks to bar Kalshi event contracts in New York
Regulation2 min read
Summary
New York Attorney General Letitia James refiled a proposed temporary restraining order seeking to stop Kalshi offering event contracts in or from New York, or to people there, without a state gaming licence. The proposed order would bar purchases by people under 21 and target advertising, marketing and solicitation for covered contracts.
New York Attorney General Letitia James refiled a proposed temporary restraining order in Manhattan Supreme Court on Friday seeking to stop Kalshi immediately from offering sports, culture, election and other contracts in New York. The proposed restriction would cover contracts offered within or from New York or to people in the state without an NYSGC licence.
The proposed order would also prevent Kalshi from allowing anyone under 21 to buy covered event contracts. Gaming attorney Daniel Wallach said it also targets promotion and solicitation for those contracts, including references to campuses and university-owned media. He warned that exchanges based in New York could face major implications; Kalshi and Polymarket are both headquartered there.
The CFTC issued the proposal on 9 October, aiming to broaden the Commodity Exchange Act’s definition of swaps to cover contracts linked to sports, politics, culture and weather. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig views the products as commodity derivatives under the agency’s exclusive jurisdiction, according to the report.
The coalition’s comment letter argues that prediction markets permit sports wagering without the state oversight imposed on traditional sportsbooks. The attorneys general believe the proposal could make it easier for platforms to evade licensing, age restrictions and problem-gambling safeguards. They also contend that the agency lacks a quorum to adopt the rule, with only one commissioner serving. They cite federal appeals court rulings against the CFTC’s asserted authority over sports betting and want clarification that sports betting contracts are not swaps under its jurisdiction.
A divided Fourth Circuit appeals court sided with Maryland, rejecting Kalshi’s appeal against allowing gaming regulators to pursue enforcement over unlicensed sports-event contracts. The Fourth Circuit decision was 2-1 in the regulator’s favour; Kalshi said the judges’ separate opinions showed a lack of a unified legal argument against prediction markets. Kalshi lost unanimously in the Ninth and Sixth circuits, but the Third Circuit ruled that New Jersey gaming regulators could not prohibit sports-event contracts.
Kalshi co-founder Tarek Mansour called the Third Circuit ruling a win for the industry. James Baker, acting director of the Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Agency, said the state was evaluating its next steps after the Fourth Circuit decision.