Federal judge denies CFTC bid to block New York Kalshi action
Regulation2 min read
Summary
US District Judge Lorna Schofield denied the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s emergency request to stop New York pursuing enforcement action against Kalshi. She found that the CFTC had not shown a likelihood of success in arguing that federal law prevents states enforcing gambling rules against federally regulated prediction markets. A New York state-court hearing on a temporary restraining order was scheduled for 23 November.
A federal judge denied the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s emergency request to stop New York’s enforcement action against Kalshi. U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield denied the request Friday. She found that the agency had not shown it was likely to succeed in arguing that federal law bars states from applying gambling rules to federally regulated prediction markets.
New York’s lawsuit accuses Kalshi of operating unlicensed gambling in violation of state law. Kalshi contends that its offerings are derivatives subject exclusively to federal regulation by the CFTC, overriding state gambling rules. Schofield noted that three appellate courts had ruled against Kalshi; another ruled for the operator, leaving conflicting decisions on whether the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state gambling rules.
The CFTC argued in its 20 November filing that New York’s requested order could effectively close Kalshi’s nationwide operations because the company is headquartered in the state. The proposed order would prohibit Kalshi from operating within or from New York. The CFTC argued that the wording could pose an existential threat to its registrants, marketplaces and regulatory jurisdiction.
Kalshi warned that the proposed order would bar it from operating from its New York headquarters, with possible effects on customers and trading across the U.S. The company asked the judge in a November 19 letter to hear arguments from both sides before granting a temporary restraining order. It also argued that the order would conflict with an August CFTC directive requiring its exchange to remain open even if a court told it to block New York.
In a 20 November response, New York accused Kalshi of repeatedly seeking to delay enforcement while continuing to profit from customers in the state. The attorney general’s office argued that the order would stop Kalshi offering unlicensed gambling products rather than close its operations nationwide. The state said Kalshi lets users under 21 bet on sports, including New York college teams, and that state sports betting laws prohibit both.
Schofield’s decision followed a federal judge’s ruling the previous day returning New York’s enforcement lawsuit to state court. New York County Supreme Court has scheduled a hearing for 23 November on Attorney General Letitia James’s request to prevent Kalshi offering sports event contracts in the state.