CFTC proposal draws 140 comments on sports event contracts
Regulation2 min read
Summary
The CFTC proposal to classify sports event contracts as swaps drew 140 public comments by the 18 November deadline. Prediction-market operators and financial participants supported federal oversight, while tribal organisations, 43 states and Washington, D.C., opposed the measure over sovereignty and gambling-regulation concerns.
A CFTC proposal to classify sports event contracts as swaps received 140 public comments by the 18 November deadline, with most arriving in the final two days, according to a report. Tribal organisations led opposition, citing threats to sovereignty and gambling rules, while prediction-market operators and financial industry participants backed federal oversight.
A coalition representing 43 states and Washington, D.C., called for the proposal to be dropped, arguing that the CFTC has no statutory power to recast sports bets as financial derivatives. The National Congress of American Indians, which represents approximately 300 tribal nations, also sought withdrawal. The organisation said Congress did not intend the CFTC to regulate gambling.
A Ninth Circuit ruling for two California tribes against Kalshi was cited in several submissions. The court held that sports event contracts on tribal land could breach the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, including when classified as swaps.
Of the four tribes partnered with Kalshi, three filed supportive comments; the Kletsel Dehe Wintun Nation did not submit one. Oklahoma’s Alabama-Quassarte Tribal Town, where the partnership is the subject of an internal dispute, showed the strongest support. The tribe argued that federal event contracts and tribal gaming could operate under separate regulatory systems without weakening IGRA. As an example of commercial use, it cited a reported $60,000 Kalshi position taken by a Los Angeles hospitality group to hedge against the Dodgers missing the World Series. Letters from Alturas Indian Rancheria and Greenville Rancheria broadly backed regulatory certainty and a role for tribes in emerging financial markets.
Utah Gov. Spencer Cox and Attorney General Derek Brown submitted a separate letter warning of possible addiction, household financial harm and loss of state regulatory authority from expanding sports event contracts. Nevada Rep. Dina Titus also opposed the proposal and was the only sitting lawmaker to comment. The American Gaming Association argued that the framework would apply different treatment to products it considers functionally equivalent. The association also questioned the CFTC’s grasp of the sports event contract market’s size. The CFTC assessment cited $1.5 billion in monthly trading activity; the figure exceeded $39 billion in the first week of November alone. Boyd Gaming also opposed the proposal, warning that an excessively broad swap definition could eventually include conventional casino games, even though another proposed rule would exclude them.
An advance notice of proposed rulemaking in April attracted more than 3,500 comments, while a July proposal received more than 1,400. The latest rulemaking has a narrower focus: whether event contracts are swaps, rather than a comprehensive set of trading regulations. The CFTC must consider the submissions before deciding whether to finalise or revise its proposal.