CFTC nominees decline to take firm stance on sports event contracts
Regulation2 min read
Summary
Donald Trump’s CFTC nominees Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland declined to give a definitive view on how sports event contracts should be regulated during a Senate hearing. Anonick said the legal question was complex, while Rowland cited active litigation and voiced sympathy for state and tribal concerns.
CFTC nominees Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland did not take a definitive position at a Senate hearing on whether federal or state regulators should oversee sports event contracts.
The disagreement among federal courts makes the answer difficult, Annonick said. He acknowledged that there may be grounds to leave regulation of gaming event contracts to states. He interpreted the CEA as giving the CFTC discretion to find a contract contrary to the public interest when it meets specified factors, including gaming. Rowland said active litigation constrained his comments, but he was sympathetic to individual states’ concerns and prepared to work with them if confirmed.
The nominees also faced questions from Democratic Senator Adam Schiff and colleagues who have questioned whether sports event contracts are legal under the federal framework. Democratic Senator Tina Smith asked Annonick whether there was a practical distinction between sports wagers and sports event contracts. Responding to that question, Annonick described the issue as emotional and sensitive.
CFTC chairman Michael Selig has argued that the regulator should retain exclusive authority over event contracts, including those involving sports. Prediction market platforms Kalshi and Polymarket have argued that compliance with individual state gaming laws would threaten their status as federally regulated exchanges. Democratic Senator Amy Klobuchar has said state gaming regulators should have the final say over contracts involving gaming and other activities, including war, terrorism and assassination.
State regulators and attorneys general see the issue as straightforward: sports event contracts essentially emulate gambling, even though they are regulated differently. The public also tends to disagree with Annonick’s view of the issue’s complexity: in a recent American Gaming Association survey, 80% of respondents said prediction markets were gambling and should be regulated as such.