43 state attorneys general urge CFTC to withdraw proposed sports contract rule
Regulation2 min read
Summary
Attorneys general from 43 US states and the District of Columbia urged the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to withdraw its proposed rule on sports event contracts in a comment submitted on 18 November. They argued the proposal could undermine state gambling laws and exceed the CFTC’s authority; the commission’s consultation ended that day.
A proposed CFTC rule classifying sports-related event contracts as swaps should be withdrawn, according to attorneys general from 43 U.S. states and the District of Columbia, who argue it would undermine state gambling regulations and exceed the agency’s authority. The bipartisan coalition submitted its formal comment to the CFTC on 18 November, the consultation period’s final day. Officials from Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee and Utah co-led the effort with Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson.
The CFTC published the proposal on 9 October to amend the Commodity Exchange Act's definition of a swap to explicitly cover contracts based on sports, political, cultural and weather events. The commission maintains that the products are commodity derivatives within its jurisdiction. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig has argued that the changes would clarify how federal commodities law applies to event contracts.
According to the attorneys general, the CFTC should not oversee sports contracts on prediction platforms, while states should keep control of sports betting and consumer safeguards. They point to federal appellate rulings that they say contradict the agency's assertion of authority over sports betting. The group also warned that the rule could let prediction platforms circumvent state licensing, age limits and protections against problem gambling. Existing sportsbooks could reorganise as prediction markets to evade state gambling law, the group cautioned, potentially depriving consumers of established regulatory safeguards.
The attorneys general also questioned whether the CFTC can muster the quorum to adopt the rule, since only one commissioner currently serves. In the coalition's view, the CEA's vacancy provision does not empower a sole commissioner to act independently for the agency. Its letter says a quorum requires at least two commissioners and possibly four. President Donald Trump nominated Republican Nathan Anonick and Democrat Matthew Rowland for the commission on 12 November. Both are currently legal advisers to the Senate Agriculture Committee.
In July, Ohio had jointly led a bipartisan group of 44 attorneys general seeking CFTC recognition of states' authority over sports prediction markets. Nevada's top gaming regulator has criticised the commission's approach. Separately, nine Democratic senators asked Selig to retract an interpretation on geofencing issued on 5 November. An interim measure already in force is distinct from the proposal and leaves conventional sportsbook bets and casino games outside the definition of swaps.