New York mayor criticises prediction markets over gambling risks
Regulation2 min read
Summary
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has criticised prediction markets, warning that contracts covering politics, sport and everyday events could make gambling routine. He questioned the social effects of platforms including Kalshi and Polymarket and linked their expanding customer base to concerns about gambling addiction. Combined trading activity on the two platforms reportedly reached about $24bn in April 2026.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani warned that prediction markets could make gambling routine by allowing wagers on an expanding range of events. Speaking at the DealBook Summit, he questioned the social effects of platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket, where contracts cover political events, sport and other outcomes. He raised concerns about gambling addiction as the platforms draw more customers.
Mamdani said he had not used either platform, but had friends who traded contracts on entertainment outcomes.
Combined trading on Kalshi and Polymarket reportedly climbed from less than $5bn in September 2025 to roughly $24bn in April 2026. Kalshi had $114.8bn in notional trading volume in the 30-day period ending November 18, according to analytics platform DeFi Rate. Polymarket's US operation registered a further $16.4bn during that period.
Nearly 70% of prediction market participants lose money, according to account analyses, while reportedly more than two-thirds of profits accrue to just 0.1% of accounts. The platforms have also reportedly drawn people shut out of traditional sportsbooks after bans or financial problems.
State regulators and officials have sought to restrict the platforms through cease-and-desist notices and legal action; some company representatives have also faced criminal charges. At issue in several disputes is whether operators belong under federal Commodity Futures Trading Commission oversight or individual state gambling rules. The National Football League wants the US Supreme Court to make prediction markets comply with state sports betting laws, while New Jersey has called for greater state authority over the sector. New York Attorney General Letitia James has sued Polymarket and Kalshi, alleging they run an illegal gambling business without the required licence.
A teleprompter operator at the White House was fined and put on leave for betting on what presidential speeches would contain before they were delivered. Separately, a US Army soldier faced charges for allegedly wagering on an American military operation in Venezuela using classified information.
Opposition to betting on election results stood at 60% among Americans, with comparable levels among Democratic and Republican respondents, a Reuters/Ipsos poll conducted last month found.
Polymarket founder Shayne Coplan dismissed suggestions that his company's connections with Donald Trump Jr. were unusual when questioned at the DealBook Summit. Trump Jr. is a Polymarket advisory board member and held a comparable role at Kalshi until recently.