Mamdani questions prediction markets’ expansion in New York
Regulation2 min read
Summary
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani criticised prediction markets’ expansion into wider areas, saying they reduce aspects of life to bets. He said he had never traded event contracts and was troubled by addiction associated with the growing customer base.
The expansion of prediction markets into more areas of life drew criticism from New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who argued that turning everything into a bet diminishes life. He said he had never traded event contracts and expressed concern about addiction among an expanding customer base.
Mamdani said predicting outcomes such as Rotten Tomatoes scores for new films was humorous, but raised concerns about more serious health effects.
Mamdani cited Kalshi probabilities during his 2025 campaign, including when the platform estimated his chance of winning the Democratic primary at roughly 40%, according to Justin Slaughter, a Paradigm senior adviser and former CFTC official. Trading on the outcome of the November 2025 New York City mayoral election totaled approximately $541.3 million among Kalshi and Polymarket users; Mamdani defeated Republican Curtis Sliwa and independent Andrew Cuomo. Polymarket's historical data show Mamdani overtaking Cuomo in June 2025 and remaining in the lead through the rest of the campaign.
Slaughter said at a Kalshi event in Washington, D.C. that every campaign manager he had met during the election cycle had used prediction markets to gather information. He said he expected many members taking office to have cited Kalshi privately to donors and staff.
To curb the spread of prediction markets, state regulators and officials have pursued measures ranging from cease-and-desist letters and legal challenges to criminal charges against company officials. In the 30-day period ending Nov. 18, Kalshi recorded $114.8 billion in notional trading volume, according to analytics platform DeFi Rate. Polymarket's U.S. hub recorded $16.4 billion over the same period.