Italy’s Supreme Court upholds ADM betting-tax assessment against CTD operator
Regulation2 min read
Summary
Italy’s Court of Cassation rejected an appeal by the holder of a data-transmission centre serving an unlicensed foreign bookmaker. The ruling left ADM’s betting-tax assessment in force and confirmed the centre holder’s status as a taxpayer for the activity.
Italy’s Court of Cassation rejected an appeal by the holder of a data transmission centre working for an unlicensed foreign bookmaker. The decision leaves ADM’s betting-tax assessment in force.
ADM prevailed before Lazio’s second-instance tax court after the assessment had been annulled at first instance in Latina. The judges deemed the agency’s appeal timely, applying an eleven-month suspension of appeal deadlines for disputes eligible for settlement under law no. 197/2022. On the merits, the tax court had recognised the centre holder as liable for the tax. The Court of Cassation found that the appeal court had expressly ruled on the holder’s role and left the decision in place.
The centre provided premises, received and transmitted bets, collected and transferred stakes, and paid any winnings. The tax court held that those activities gave rise to liability even though the holder did not directly assume economic risk on the bets.
The taxpayer challenged the timeliness of notification and the way the administration had sent the assessment to the municipality of Terracina, saying a municipal officer had delivered it by hand. The Court of Cassation ruled that ground inadmissible, citing a 2021 ruling on when notification takes effect. The relevant time for determining whether the administration met its assessment deadline is when it completed the steps needed to submit the document for notification; delivery to the taxpayer can follow later. The court found ADM’s use of a municipal officer permissible.
The appellant also challenged the lack of a new summons after a meeting was postponed because of the health emergency, as well as the notice’s reasoning and the estimated tax calculation. The appellant said the notice omitted the bookmaker’s identity and the betting flows in dispute, and that the estimate overlooked the business’s recent opening and limited customer base. The court ruled that ground inadmissible because it combined different objections without allowing them to be considered separately. It said there was no general obligation to hear the taxpayer before a betting-tax assessment and that the factual objections sought a fresh assessment outside its remit.
The court awarded ADM €5,900 in fees, plus expenses recorded as a debt. It ordered the appellant to pay a further €5,900 to ADM and €3,000 to the Cassa delle ammende after the appellant sought a panel decision following a proposed accelerated resolution, which the panel followed. An additional court fee is payable if due. The order does not state the assessed tax or name the bookmaker.