Italian tax court upholds ADM assessment exceeding €1.2m
Enforcement & compliance2 min read
Summary
An Italian second-instance tax court upheld an ADM assessment against a former association president over four unauthorised, altered gaming machines. The dispute covers more than €1.2m in PREU and sanctions, plus interest and costs, after the court rejected arguments based on his resignation and the timing of the machines’ installation.
An Italian second-instance tax court rejected a former association president's appeal against an ADM assessment concerning irregular gaming machines. The dispute involves more than €1.2m in gaming machine tax, known as PREU, and sanctions, plus interest and costs.
A 2018 inspection found four operating machines without the required authorisations or a connection to the telematic network. A subsequent technical examination found altered security seals, unauthorised control devices and tampered counters, preventing a detailed reconstruction of play.
For each machine, the office calculated a presumed taxable base of 3mila euro a day over the 365 days before the inspection; the daily amount was not the tax owed.
The former president argued he was not responsible because he had left office more than three months before the machines were seized. He disputed the evidence that the machines had been present during his tenure and sought, alternatively, to limit tax and sanctions to his days in office in 2018.
The court rejected his arguments, finding that the presumed operating period included months when he was president and legal representative. The judges said leaving office before the inspection did not establish that the machines had been absent during his tenure.
The court said the administration had documented the machines' discovery, their alteration and the role he held during the relevant period. It said he had to challenge the presumed timeline with evidence such as purchase or rental invoices, installation contracts or transport documents showing the machines arrived later.
The court ruled inadmissible a declaration first submitted on appeal and an associated request for witness testimony. Written witness testimony is permitted in tax proceedings within specific limits and subject to a judge's assessment. New evidence on appeal is subject to conditions, including that it is indispensable or could not have been presented at first instance for reasons not attributable to the party.
The court rejected a request to apportion the debt, finding that the administration could seek the entire obligation relating to the management period from each jointly liable party, subject to a right of recourse between them. The court's confirmation of the assessment was accompanied by costs for the appeal proceedings.