Italian tax court cuts slot-machine PREU assessment to €18,000
Regulation2 min read
Summary
An Italian tax court reduced the tax assessment against a Sicilian company that owns AWP machines to a higher PREU charge of about €18,000. The Customs and Monopolies Agency had sought more than €34 million in tax, penalties and interest, but the court found the meter discrepancies insufficient to support an indirect reconstruction of sums played.
An Italian tax court reduced a tax assessment against a Sicilian slot-machine owner to about €18,000 in additional PREU, after ADM sought more than €34m in tax, penalties and interest. The court found that meter discrepancies on some machines did not justify an assessment of that size.
ADM inspections in December 2017 covered 48 machines installed at commercial premises. Officials found differences between data stored on game boards and data sent to control devices. The discrepancies affected 22 machines and were confined to September and October 2017.
ADM used a presumptive calculation under law 190/2014 to estimate unpaid PREU at more than €9.5m. It added nearly €23m in penalties, equivalent to 240% of the disputed tax, and more than €1.6m in interest. About €21.9m of the claim was later entered for collection and demanded through a payment notice.
The rules permit the presumptive method for machines disconnected from the state network or whose data on amounts played cannot be read, including because of tampering. All the machines in this case were connected, and inspectors found only differences between recorded and transmitted values. The court therefore ruled that the presumptive method did not apply. The judges said a claim exceeding €34m was unreasonable given that the anomalies affected some machines and covered two months.
A related criminal investigation into possible irregular operation of the machines ended with a decision not to proceed and the release of seized property. A technical assessment requested during the inquiries was not available in the tax case file.
The company calculated a taxable amount of €95,000 and additional PREU of €18,000 using the recorded meter differences. The court accepted the calculation, which ADM had not contested. The revised PREU affects the challenged payment notice only as regards the machine tax. Penalties and interest remain to be adjusted to the new taxable amount.