High Court rejects negligence claim against Betfair in UK
Regulation2 min read
Summary
The High Court dismissed the Ashton family’s negligence claim against Betfair on 13 November. The court found insufficient evidence of a gambling disorder and rejected the argument that regulatory social-responsibility requirements automatically created a civil duty of care.
The High Court threw out Luke Ashton’s family’s negligence case against Betfair in full, finding that the wider duty of care they alleged did not apply. Mr Justice Swift delivered the judgment on 13 November. The defendant was TSE Malta LP, a Flutter Entertainment entity that operates the Betfair Exchange.
Ashton had gambled for many years before dying by suicide in April 2021, at age 40. His family claimed that Betfair had made an alleged gambling disorder worse and contributed materially to his death. Betfair disputed the allegations.
The family said the operator should have spotted indications of gambling harm, intervened earlier and followed the Gambling Commission’s social responsibility requirements. Under those rules, licensees must identify customers potentially at risk of gambling harm and engage with them appropriately. Justice Swift rejected the proposition that regulatory requirements could simply be converted into a negligence duty. The court considered the standards unsuitable as a direct test of legal liability, even though they aim to reduce gambling harm generally. The judge placed considerable emphasis on individual choice and personal responsibility.
Psychiatric evidence presented for the claimants argued that Mr Ashton satisfied most diagnostic criteria for severe gambling disorder under DSM-5. Their expert believed his condition had deteriorated over time, peaking in severity shortly before he died. Betfair’s expert took the opposing view, saying the evidence was too limited to establish a diagnosis. The court had largely been given betting records, not material about Mr Ashton’s feelings, motivations and thoughts. The defence expert cautioned that gambling behaviour by itself was not a reliable way to determine whether a person met the disorder’s clinical criteria.
Swift accepted the defence evidence, finding too little to establish that Ashton had a gambling disorder of any kind. He said that, if required to decide, he would find Ashton did not satisfy the DSM-5 criteria. The judge consequently found that Betfair neither knew nor could reasonably have been expected to know of a foreseeable risk that Ashton would develop a severe gambling disorder. The court’s identified duty of care thus did not come into effect.
The Gambling Commission examined the circumstances after Mr Ashton died, the judgment noted. In 2021, the regulator initially found no need for action, though a coroner subsequently raised concerns in a Prevention of Future Deaths report.