High Court dismisses Betfair negligence claim and outlines limited duty of care in UK
Regulation2 min read
Summary
London’s High Court dismissed the Ashton family’s negligence claim against Betfair on 13 November, ruling that the evidence did not establish gambling disorder. The judge rejected a general duty to protect customers from their betting decisions but said a limited duty could arise where severe gambling disorder was reasonably foreseeable.
London’s High Court has dismissed a family’s negligence claim against Betfair; the former customer died by suicide in April 2021. In his 13 November judgment, Mr Justice Jonathan Swift rejected the claim concerning Luke Ashton, finding insufficient evidence that he had suffered from gambling disorder.
Swift rejected a general duty for gambling companies to protect customers from their betting decisions, but accepted that a limited duty could arise when severe gambling disorder was reasonably foreseeable. Such a duty might arise if an operator knew a customer had been diagnosed with gambling disorder, or if betting activity showed a complete loss of control. Swift said the appropriate intervention in those circumstances would be to stop providing gambling services to the customer.
Annie Ashton, his widow, and other relatives alleged that Betfair let him keep gambling despite indications of serious difficulties. They contended during the proceedings that the platform and promotional activity had created or sustained the risk. The defendant was TSE Malta LP, the Flutter Entertainment entity responsible for Betfair.
Dr John Barker, the family’s psychiatric expert, concluded that Ashton satisfied eight of the nine DSM-5 criteria for a gambling disorder diagnosis. Betfair’s expert, Dr Humphrey Needham-Bennett, disagreed, considering the material inadequate without information about Ashton’s thoughts, motivations and emotional experiences. The judge favoured that assessment, concluding that betting and financial records alone could not establish the subjective elements of a clinical diagnosis. Ashton had not been formally diagnosed with gambling disorder while alive. Without adequate medical evidence of the condition, the court could not establish that Betfair knew or reasonably ought to have known of the psychiatric injury risk alleged by the family.
The family said Betfair’s obligations under the Gambling Commission’s social responsibility code supported the establishment of a duty of care. The judge rejected the proposition that noncompliance with regulatory standards should automatically lead to civil liability. He cited Section 24(8) of the Gambling Act 2005, under which a code breach alone does not give rise to a civil claim.
Annie Ashton had earlier challenged the Gambling Commission’s decision against taking enforcement action against Betfair. A spokesperson for Flutter UK & Ireland welcomed the ruling and expressed condolences to Mrs Ashton and her family.