SectorWire
SearchRegister
MenuClose

Fourth Circuit rejects Kalshi challenge to Maryland sports betting rules

Regulation2 min read

Summary

The US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2–1 against Kalshi, upholding a decision that allows Maryland to pursue action over the company’s sports event contracts. The majority found Kalshi had not shown that federal commodities law clearly removed Maryland’s authority to enforce its gambling rules; the judges issued separate opinions, including a dissent supporting Kalshi.

The US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled two to one in Maryland's favour, upholding a decision that allowed the state to pursue action against Kalshi over sports betting. The court found that the prediction market operator had not shown federal commodities law prevented Maryland from enforcing its sports betting rules.

The dispute started when Maryland accused Kalshi of unlicensed sports wagering in a cease-and-desist letter sent in April 2025. In New Jersey and some other jurisdictions, courts have concluded that state gambling laws are likely superseded by federal commodities law.

Congress had not clearly stripped Maryland of its gambling authority, even if Kalshi's sports event contracts were swaps, Judge Roger Gregory concluded in the leading opinion. He also rejected the company's claim that state licensing rules conflicted with federal law. In his view, Kalshi could meet federal commodities rules alongside Maryland's gambling requirements. He found that Maryland was not seeking to regulate derivatives markets generally, but required sports wagering providers to be licensed and follow rules on advertising and consumer protection.

Kalshi's contracts did not qualify as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act because payouts hinged on sporting results rather than the events occurring, Judge Stephanie Thacker concluded. She warned that the company's position could make almost every sports wager in America a federally regulated swap, moving oversight from states to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).

Dissenting judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin found that the contracts qualified as swaps and fell under the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction. Benjamin argued that sporting outcomes could affect sponsors, broadcasters, hospitality businesses and other commercial interests, giving the contracts the potential financial and economic consequences required under the Commodity Exchange Act. She noted that lawmakers had discussed sporting event contracts while developing rules on event contracts and gaming under the Dodd-Frank Act.

This story so far

Request a correction

Flag an issue

Keep reading