European Court of Justice leaves Malta’s Bill 55 question unresolved
Regulation2 min read
Summary
The European Court of Justice declared the Vienna Commercial Court’s request for a preliminary ruling inadmissible in a case concerning Malta’s Bill 55. It did not decide whether the Maltese gambling rule is compatible with European law, finding that answer unnecessary to resolve the liability proceedings before the Vienna court.
The European Court of Justice declared a request from the Vienna Commercial Court inadmissible on 19 November 2026, leaving undecided whether Malta’s Bill 55 is compatible with European law.
The court said the questions referred by Vienna did not need to be answered to resolve the underlying liability proceedings. The issue was instead whether the legal opinion at the centre of the case was defensible under the information and legal standards available when it was prepared.
Austria’s Spielerschutz Sigma Prozessfinanzierungs GmbH had commissioned a law firm to examine the Maltese legislation. The resulting opinion concluded that Bill 55 plainly breached European law. After a Maltese court refused to enforce an Austrian judgment under the rule, the litigation funder sought damages and reimbursement of the opinion fee, among other remedies.
Malta created Article 56A of its gambling law when it introduced the measure in 2023. The provision is designed to block Malta from recognising or enforcing certain foreign judgments against companies holding Maltese gambling licences. The measure arose amid numerous cases in which players from Germany and Austria sought to recover online gambling losses.
Advocate general Nicholas Emiliou had advised on 23 April 2026 that the request should be found inadmissible. He nevertheless concluded that a national rule intended to prevent categorically the recognition and enforcement of certain foreign judgments against gambling operators was incompatible with European rules.
The European Commission opened separate infringement proceedings against Malta on 18 June 2025. The Commission considers the rule incompatible with European provisions on the recognition and enforcement of judgments. It objects in particular to the requirement for Maltese courts to reject certain foreign judgments systematically, which it says undermines mutual trust between member states’ justice systems. The court’s ruling does not end the infringement proceedings.
On 26 October 2026, Malta’s appeal court referred seven questions to the European Court of Justice in a dispute between TSG Interactive Gaming Europe Ltd and Gerhard Posch. That case concerns whether Malta may refuse to recognise and enforce an Austrian judgment by relying on its gambling legislation.