CJEU leaves Malta Bill 55 EU compliance unresolved
Regulation1 min read
Summary
The CJEU declined to assess whether Malta’s Bill 55 complies with EU rules on recognising judgments. The court said that question was unnecessary to resolve Spielerschutz Sigma’s negligence claim over legal advice, leaving the legislation active and its compatibility open to future challenges.
Malta’s Bill 55 is still in force and its compatibility with EU law remains unsettled after the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) declined to rule on it.
Malta introduced Bill 55 in June 2023 as Article 56A of its Gaming Act. It blocks legal actions in Malta against gambling companies licensed there, provided their activities are legal locally. It requires Maltese courts to dismiss foreign judgments arising from such claims.
In February, a Maltese civil court refused to enforce an Austrian ruling. The ruling had ordered an MGA-licensed operator to repay a player nearly €500,000.
Austrian litigation funder Spielerschutz Sigma Prozessfinanzierungs GmbH backs players seeking to recover gambling losses from Malta-licensed operators accused of providing services without Austrian authorisation. A legal adviser had previously asserted that Bill 55 was clearly incompatible with EU law. The funder sued for negligence, arguing that the advice caused it direct financial harm.
Austria asked the CJEU to consider the law’s compatibility with EU judgment-recognition rules, focusing on the Brussels I Recast Regulation and Malta’s refusal to honour EU-wide rulings. The CJEU said the obligations arising from the legal consultation were independent of whether the Maltese legislation complied with EU law.