CJEU returns Malta Bill 55 case to Austria without ruling on legality
Regulation1 min read
Summary
The CJEU sent the Austrian referral on Malta’s Bill 55 back to the Vienna court without deciding whether the law complies with EU law. It said that question was unnecessary to resolve the professional-negligence claim; the Maltese measure aims to stop enforcement in Malta of some gambling judgments issued elsewhere in the EU.
The Court of Justice of the European Union declined to decide whether Malta’s Bill 55 complies with EU law. The court sent the case back to Austria, concluding that the bill’s legality was unnecessary to resolve the professional negligence dispute.
Malta introduced Bill 55 in 2023 through amendments to its Gambling Act to protect Malta-licensed operators from enforcement of certain judgments issued in other EU countries. The Maltese government has argued that the law accords with EU principles of free movement and freedom to provide services.
In Austria, players have pursued gambling losses from Malta-based operators without domestic licences. Spielerschutz Sigma has funded legal claims by Austrian players seeking compensation. After Bill 55 was introduced, the organisation worked with an Austrian legal practice to assess whether the law complied with EU law. According to the organisation, the opinion concluded that the bill conflicted with European legal principles and should not apply in Maltese courts.
Spielerschutz Sigma then sued the firm behind the opinion for compensation over alleged professional negligence. In 2024, the Commercial Court of Vienna sent the case to the CJEU, seeking clarity on whether Malta’s legislation complied with European law.
Players in Germany are continuing to pursue court claims to recover gambling losses from Malta-licensed operators.