Chile’s Supreme Court challenges bill on blocking betting platforms
Regulation1 min read
Summary
Chile’s Supreme Court said proposed amendments to strengthen court-ordered blocking of betting platforms were unnecessary and redundant under existing civil-procedure rules. In a report sent to the Senate on 12 November, the court said technical and network factors, rather than a lack of judicial powers, create the main blocking difficulties and recommended sector-specific legislation.
Chile’s Supreme Court said proposed changes to enforce court-ordered blocking of betting platforms were unnecessary because judges already have powers to enforce their rulings. The court sent its assessment to the Senate presidency on 12 November and released it on 18 November.
Bill 18.699-07 would amend the Code of Civil Procedure to prevent operators from continuing through new domains, subdomains or mirror sites after an access restriction. Introduced by lawmakers, it is at its first constitutional stage and has no legislative urgency status. The court said the three proposed provisions, Articles 238 bis, 238 ter and 238 quáter, were redundant in light of existing enforcement rules in the code.
The court said effective blocking was hampered by technical and network operating factors rather than a lack of judicial powers or opportunities for procedural debate. After reviewing the bill in a full court session on 9 November, the justices identified a mismatch between internet blocking technology and the proposed mechanism.
The court questioned placing platform-specific blocking rules in a code intended for general civil procedure. It recommended that lawmakers reconsider the approach and pursue potential reforms through sector-specific legislation.