TJSC rejects retroactive betting refunds after ludopathy diagnosis
Regulation2 min read
Santa Catarina's Court of Justice upheld a decision rejecting a bettor's claims for refunds and damages against an online betting platform. The court said a diagnosis issued in March 2026 did not invalidate bets placed between 2021 and December 2024, including transactions made before Law 14.790/2023 and Brazil's regulated market.
Santa Catarina’s Court of Justice upheld a ruling rejecting a bettor’s claims for refunds and damages against an online betting platform. The court held that a gambling disorder diagnosis issued after the bets did not invalidate them retroactively.
The medical report was issued in March 2026, while the disputed deposits were made between 2021 and December 2024. The reporting judge said the report’s retrospective assessment of earlier symptoms did not establish that the bettor had been diagnosed during the transactions.
The judge said Law 14.790/2023 prohibits betting by people diagnosed with gambling disorder by a qualified professional and makes transactions that breach the prohibition void. The provision applied to formally diagnosed people and could not be extended to earlier bets on the basis of a later diagnosis. Many disputed transactions preceded the law, published on 30 December 2023, and all came before the regulated fixed-odds betting market began on 1 January 2025.
The bettor had sought the return of deposits less withdrawals, damages and a finding that the platform had failed in its duties to monitor and protect users. On appeal, the bettor argued that the refusal to order disclosure of the full account history and an accounting examination had restricted the defence. The bettor argued that the law did not require a diagnosis at the time of the bets for them to be declared void.
The reporting judge rejected the defence argument, saying the existing documents were sufficient and the requested evidence would not change the conclusion because the dispute principally concerned legal questions.
The judge said there was no proof that the platform knew of the bettor’s condition or that the bettor had requested an account block, self-exclusion or betting limits. Nor was a causal link established between promotional messages received and the alleged losses. An exclusion of liability under the Consumer Protection Code therefore applied because neither a service failure nor a causal link to the claimed damages had been proved.
The court’s fourth civil law chamber unanimously dismissed the appeal and upheld the judgment.