SectorWire
SearchRegister
MenuClose

Italy’s Cassation Court confirms eight-thousand-euro betting sanction

Regulation2 min read

Summary

Italy’s Court of Cassation rejected an appeal on 10 November 2026 and confirmed an eight-thousand-euro administrative sanction against an outlet collecting bets for a foreign operator without police authorisation. The court said a TULPS Article 86 authorisation for lawful games does not replace the Article 88 licence required for betting collection; the case followed a March 2014 inspection and a 2018 ADM order.

An administrative penalty of 8mila euro (eight thousand euros) against a venue operator stands after Italy’s Court of Cassation dismissed an appeal in an order published on 10 November 2026. A permit for lawful games under Article 86 of the TULPS is not a substitute for the Article 88 licence needed to collect bets.

The case followed a March 2014 inspection of a venue with four machines that was collecting bets for a foreign operator without the required police authorisation. A court and subsequently the Catania Court of Appeal upheld an order issued by ADM in 2018.

The venue operator challenged the need for an additional licence, arguing that the Italian system was discriminatory and invoking EU freedoms of establishment and provision of services. The court’s second civil division rejected those arguments.

The court said a system requiring a concession and public security authorisation was not in itself disproportionate to the aim of combating gambling-related crime. It said authorisation in an operator’s home state did not prevent another member state from requiring its own permission for services offered on its territory, subject to EU law.

The court said setting aside national rules required an assessment of the specific circumstances. A party alleging discrimination must show that the foreign operator failed to obtain the required permissions because it was unlawfully excluded from tenders or faced discriminatory conduct by national authorities. The court found that this had not been demonstrated in the case. The judges said challenges to tender conditions did not document that the operator had participated in the procedures cited and was subsequently excluded on discriminatory grounds.

The court rejected a request for another preliminary reference to the Court of Justice, citing established principles in European case law. It rejected the argument that legal uncertainty removed the venue operator’s liability. The order said merely alleging an uncertain legal framework was insufficient to establish an absence of fault in the administrative offence.

The operator had requested the more favourable treatment introduced by law no. 190 of 2014, which provides for a €1,500 penalty for each machine installed in breach of the specific prohibition. The court ruled that the provision did not apply retroactively because it did not expressly extend the lighter regime to earlier violations and the penalty in the case was not classified as substantially criminal.

Request a correction

Flag an issue

Keep reading