SectorWire
SearchRegister
MenuClose

Evolution settles defamation case against Calcagni & Kanefsky in New Jersey

Regulation2 min read

Summary

Evolution has settled its claim against New Jersey law firm Calcagni & Kanefsky over the firm’s role in circulating a report about the supplier, according to accounts of a court hearing. The settlement removes the firm from the lawsuit, while Black Cube continues to challenge the case under New Jersey’s UPEPA; the terms remain confidential.

Lawyers for Calcagni & Kanefsky confirmed that Evolution had settled with the New Jersey law firm, removing it from the supplier’s defamation lawsuit against Black Cube. The settlement concerns the law firm’s role in circulating a report that accused Evolution of operating in prohibited markets.

The anonymous 2021 report, later found to have been produced by Black Cube, alleged that Evolution’s games were available in prohibited jurisdictions, including Iran and other countries subject to US sanctions. Calcagni & Kanefsky sent the report to gambling regulators in New Jersey and Pennsylvania, prompting investigations and media coverage. Evolution’s share price fell after the allegations, erasing billions from its market value. Evolution has rejected the allegations and said the report was part of a campaign to harm its reputation and competitive position.

Black Cube’s lawyers asked to see the settlement agreement at the Nov. 17 hearing, arguing that it could matter to the continuing case. Evolution’s lawyer withheld the terms because of confidentiality provisions. Judge John Porto suggested that releasing the terms might require a court order. Black Cube’s lawyers said they believed the deal included no payment, though that assertion has not been independently verified.

Court proceedings disclosed in October 2025 that Playtech, a competitor of Evolution, had hired Black Cube to conduct the investigation. Evolution alleges that Playtech directed an anticompetitive smear campaign while hiding its role for years. Playtech confirmed it had commissioned the inquiry, rejected any wrongdoing and maintained that the report raised legitimate concerns about Evolution’s business practices.

In February 2024, the New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement ended its inquiry into the original allegations without acting against Evolution. The regulator found no evidence that Evolution knowingly allowed its products to be offered in prohibited jurisdictions or materially benefited from their availability there.

Black Cube is asking for Evolution’s lawsuit to be dismissed under New Jersey’s Uniform Public Expression Protection Act, which guards against suits meant to suppress legitimate public participation. The agency maintains that genuine evidence underpinned its inquiry and that reports of suspected regulatory breaches are protected activity. Evolution challenges the evidence’s reliability and says the report was intended to harm it commercially. In April 2026, Evolution asked to include Playtech and other parties in the suit. Judge Porto turned down the request without prejudice in June, holding that Black Cube’s UPEPA challenge should come first.

End-of-day close Evolution (EVO), SEK, to 20 November 2026
Story date5 October 202620 November 2026

Latest reported results

Evolution Nasdaq Stockholm: EVO

Quarter ended 30 September 2026

Revenue
EUR 526.1m

Playtech LSE: PTEC

Financial year ended 31 December 2025

Revenue
EUR 763.6m
Operating income
−EUR 90.5m

Request a correction

Flag an issue

Keep reading

Regulation

New Jersey court weighs Black Cube bid to dismiss Evolution case

A New Jersey court is considering Black Cube’s bid to dismiss Evolution’s defamation case under the state’s UPEPA anti-SLAPP law. The court has deferred Evolution’s request to add Playtech until those proceedings end; lawyers for Black Cube have asked the court to examine a settlement between Evolution and law firm Calcagni & Kanefsky, whose terms were not disclosed.

Black Cube is trying to have Evolution’s defamation lawsuit thrown out in New Jersey under a state law protecting public expression. The attempt was the subject of the court’s latest hearing, held on November 17.

Continue reading