SectorWire
SearchRegister
MenuClose

EU court rejects Austrian request to rule on Malta’s Bill 55

Regulation2 min read

Summary

The Court of Justice of the European Union declared inadmissible an Austrian court’s request for guidance on Malta’s Bill 55. It said the Austrian court must decide whether a legal adviser could reasonably have defended his view of the law based on the information available at the time; a ruling on Bill 55 was unnecessary for that assessment.

An Austrian court’s request for an EU-law ruling on a Maltese provision has been declared inadmissible by the EU’s Court of Justice. The Austrian judge must assess whether the adviser’s conclusion was reasonably defensible using the rules and information available at the time; a ruling on Bill 55 is unnecessary for that assessment.

Spielerschutz Sigma asked a legal adviser about the consequences of Bill 55. The adviser had expected Malta to set the provision aside because he considered it incompatible with EU law. Spielerschutz Sigma finances claims by players seeking to recover gambling losses from online casinos.

Malta added Article 56A to its gambling law through Bill 55 in 2023. The provision requires Maltese courts, under certain conditions, to refuse foreign judgments against providers holding a Maltese gambling licence. That includes judgments concerning gambling losses in countries where those providers operated without a local licence.

Advocate general Nicholas Emiliou advised the EU court in April to leave the Austrian questions unanswered. He said that, if the court considered the substance of the case, the Maltese provision conflicted with European rules on recognising and enforcing foreign judgments.

The European Commission began a separate infringement procedure against Malta in June 2025. The Commission said Article 56A requires Maltese courts systematically to refuse certain judgments from other EU member states. It said European rules allow a country to invoke public policy for that purpose only in exceptional cases.

Request a correction

Flag an issue

Keep reading