EU court rejects Austrian judge’s reference on Malta gambling law
Regulation2 min read
Summary
The Court of Justice of the European Union declared inadmissible an Austrian judge’s request for a preliminary ruling on Malta’s gambling legislation. It said the requested interpretation of EU law was not necessary to resolve the national dispute; the decision did not rule on the Maltese law’s legality.
The Court of Justice of the European Union has ruled inadmissible an Austrian judge's request for a preliminary ruling on whether Malta's gambling law complies with EU law. The court said the requested interpretation was not needed to resolve the national dispute and did not rule on the legality of the Maltese law.
The dispute concerns Spielerschutz Sigma Prozessfinanzierungs GmbH, an Austrian company that funds lawsuits by Austrian residents who play online against operators licensed in Malta. Those operators offer services in Austria without the licence required there, allowing players to seek repayment of their losses through the courts. Spielerschutz Sigma funded numerous cases and obtained several rulings ordering operators to repay clients' losses, before seeking to have the judgments recognised and enforced in Malta.
In June 2023, Malta amended its gambling law to prevent legal actions against Maltese licence holders on public policy grounds. The changes covered recognition and enforcement by Maltese courts of foreign judgments arising from such actions.
Facing uncertainty over the changes, Spielerschutz Sigma sought legal advice on the risks to its business and the law's compatibility with EU law. The adviser said the amendment was plainly contrary to EU law and would not be applied in enforcement proceedings in Malta. A Maltese judge subsequently rejected a request by the company to recognise and enforce an Austrian judgment, citing the June 2023 amendment.
Spielerschutz Sigma then sued the legal adviser for compensation at the Vienna Commercial Court. It sought repayment of the advice fees and damages arising from cases it funded between receiving the opinion and learning that the Maltese enforcement request had been rejected. The Austrian judge referred questions to the EU court, considering that the dispute depended on whether the adviser's assessment of the Maltese law was correct.
The EU court said the Austrian judge must first assess whether the advice was reasonably defensible given the law and information available when it was provided. Under Austrian law, the adviser would not be liable if the opinion was reasonably supportable, including because it was consistent with at least some existing case law or legal scholarship. The parties' obligations under the legal advice agreement were independent of whether Malta's law complied with EU law. The questions lacked an effective connection to the national case and would amount to a request for an advisory opinion on general or hypothetical matters, outside the preliminary ruling procedure.