AGU files supporting documents in Brazil betting-measure cases
Regulation3 min read
Summary
Brazil’s Attorney General’s Office (AGU) filed four supporting documents with the Supreme Federal Court in cases challenging Provisional Measure 1,394. An analysis on a Brazilian betting industry site argued that the documents do not substantiate the AGU’s account of the measure’s policy basis; it noted that only one predated the measure and that it did not recommend a prohibition.
Brazil’s Attorney General’s Office submitted material to the Supreme Federal Court supporting federal officials’ presentations at a public hearing. It found that the four attachments did not support the office’s account of the measure’s policy basis.
The filing covers ADIs 8024, 8027, 8028 and 8035, which are before Justice Luiz Fux, and was signed on 16 November by acting Attorney General Flavio José Roman. The AGU said the documents supported federal officials’ presentations at a public hearing on 3 November. It asked the court to consider the documents alongside its submissions in ADIs 7721 and 7749.
The AGU said the measure followed monitoring of public policy and information, studies and assessments produced by federal agencies. Only one document predated the measure, a scientific literature review that did not recommend a ban.
The Health Ministry signed its technical note on 9 September 2026 to update material for ADI 7749 following a request in November 2024. A Mental Health Department dispatch was dated 30 September and signed on 1 October in response to an AGU request made after the measure. The SPA signed its note for the hearing on 29 October, while the National Secretariat for Digital Rights signed its document on 10 November, after the hearing.
The health dispatch said access to SIGAP data under a cooperation agreement between the SPA and the ministry had not yet been established. The health note said most studies it cited were observational, limiting conclusions about direct causality, and that specific Brazilian data on online betting was lacking.
Minister Alexandre Padilha’s presentation gave a figure of a 15-fold increase in suicide risk, drawn from a Swedish study of 2,099 patients diagnosed with gambling disorder. The health note cited a Norwegian study of 6,899 patients that found a 5.12-fold increase, or 2.41 times among those without another psychiatric disorder. The ministry dispatch used the 5.12 figure.
The health note reported an increase of about 140% in demand for public health services between 2018 and 2025, while Padilha’s slide gave a 200% increase for 2018 to 2026. The dispatch attributed increases of 615% and 39% to gambling, while the slide described mental health appointments generally and the number of CAPS units.
The SPA reported betting revenue of R$20.22bn in the first half of 2026, compared with R$20.07bn in the health note. The SPA note recorded 228 enforcement procedures, 106 sanction proceedings and 52,573 blocked URLs through June 2026. It recorded R$4.53bn allocated to public policies in 2025 and R$2.49bn in the first half of 2026. Of R$161.6m in balances, R$100.1m had been returned and R$61.5m was going to Caixa.
The digital rights secretariat recorded 60,677 instances of irregular betting promotion between 25 September and 9 November, including 51,611 websites and 6,596 Facebook pages. The total included 1,442 Telegram groups, 886 Instagram profiles and 127 TikTok profiles. It recorded 3,531 new items on 9 November.
The AGU said it would present further arguments on the merits when notified by the court.